Dear [AuthorFirstName] [AuthorLastName],
Thank you for sending us "[SubmissionTitle]". We appreciate the chance to read your submission; however, we feel the work is not quite the right fit for our journal at this time.
We wish you all the best with your poetry and creative endeavors.
Thank you for sending us "—". We see strong qualities in your poetry, but feel it is not a good fit for our journal at this time.
If you have something else you feel is right for our journal, please feel free to send it along during our next reading period. We wish you all the best in your poetry and creative endeavors.
Samantha Duncan Amethyst Arsenic